Josquin Masses —
The Tallis Scholars
Missa Hercules Dux Ferrarie, Missa D'ung aultre amer & Missa Faysant regretz
[4.11.2020]
hyperion-records.co.uk |
medieval.org |
amazon.es
Gimell 051
2020
[4.11.2020]
medieval.org Remarks
http://www.medieval.org/emfaq/cds/remarks.html
16 November 2020
Todd M. McComb
———
I
guess there are plenty of distractions in the world at the moment, but
it was only recently that I "noticed" that next year is a major Josquin
anniversary! I saw one release announced, then another, thinking it was
a coincidence, then a couple more &... wait a minute. Anyway, this
seems like an event that I need to cover in this space, especially
since I've generally been frustrated with the Josquin discography to
this point. Maybe next year it'll be transformed for the better.....
And while
their performances had been appealing, including as exemplifying
the next generation of conservatory technique, the programs have
generally been of the motley sort, and so haven't really grabbed
me in terms of exploring repertory (as opposed to refining technique).
When it comes to this "medieval Florentine garden" though,
most programs continue to involve a variety of composers &
sources anyway, and so a mixed program seems normal — &
in this case, actually more focused than most of their previous
releases (which have been thematic). And even the sacred tracks
bring something compelling here, seeming to fit right into the
program as a whole....
I'm
consequently going to freeze that section of my "personal list" for a
while, with the further hope that there'll be a surplus of fine items
from which to choose, and why choose too soon? I'll review items here
as they arrive, though, with an eventual update on "favorites" at some
point.... The 500th anniversary of his death also provides an impetus
to take stock of the Josquin biography, and that remains vague: Much
like Shakespeare, maybe people will never learn a satisfying amount
about the man's life, and indeed the various musical masterpieces in a
variety of styles suggest a chameleon-like personality (or even a
pseudonym for multiple authors, although I'm not making that suggestion
seriously).
And
for the most part, Josquin didn't write a series of great works in a
particular idiom, but rather a large set of "isolated" great works
(many with lesser companions) across a range of styles. That's perhaps
most true of the motets, where Josquin practically defined a new
stylistic range based on text & context, such that his masterpieces
sound unique, but of the masses as well, with the several mature
masterpieces being rather different from each other. But what continues
to amaze is that Josquin interpretations have been lagging those of his
contemporaries for compelling quality for some time now: There are no
notable programs of motets, for instance, with updated technical
interpretations (except, perhaps, those just now appearing), although
there are (finally!) a couple of very different (& rather
idiosyncratic) secular discs (coalescing around organ & lute
respectively), and really only one compelling series of mass cycles....
• • •
And The Tallis Scholars have now released the last album in that cycle,
the ninth, bringing the total to eighteen masses. Leaving aside
(problematic) notions of a canonical list, the series is also basically
in two parts, with the two albums from the 1980s (which I'd expected
they'd re-record, but apparently they won't...) being of no real value.
The other seven, though, include a variety of top flight material
— usually with one masterpiece paired with a more forgettable
cycle. This latest issue is no exception to that, as The Tallis
Scholars turn out a sparkling & energetic rendition of Josquin's
ostinato showpiece cycle, Missa Hercules Dux Ferrariae:
This is an extrovert tour-de-force & seems almost made for the
group. (Of course, this latest issue continues maddening choices like
refraining from documenting the recording dates & dividing each
mass into an unwieldy number of tracks.... The former is truly nonsense
for a group that obviously wants to be taken quite seriously. I can
only conclude that the last few items in this series were recorded
years ago, and held for release over a period of time... but I have no
real info.)
Anyway,
I wouldn't characterize the Herclues Mass as being among Josquin's most
profound, but it's masterful contrapuntally & a major entry in the
"ostinato mass" category, one that e.g. La Rue would take up more
regularly. And Josquin also wrote Missa Faysant regretz on
a very short & insistent ostinato, making for a distinctive but
less satisfying cycle: The rendering of the short motive into
sequential climaxes suggests Obrecht at times, and of course the
ostinato suggests Hercules, but the severity of the basic material also
comes to suggest something of the Missa Mater patris (from the previous Tallis Scholars program,
numbered higher than this one, suggesting they wanted to end with a
showpiece...) — the latter being the more mature elaboration
(& a cycle that seems to be growing on me now, despite dismissing
it years ago...). One might even note e.g. nascent madrigalisms or relate this thread of "insistence" in Josquin's output to e.g. Faulte d'argent....
(None of the masses on this last disc seem particularly transformative,
in fact, even if one ends up being a stylistic exhibition....)
The other item — on what is the only three mass program in the series — is then the Missa D'ung aultre amer, which replaces the benedictus with the motet Tu solus &
on this program even involves singing the Ockeghem song. And although
I've generally been content with technical choices by the Tallis
Scholars in the last seven entries in their Josquin series, they do
often lack detailed consideration, and basically opt for a consistent
overview sort of approach. In the case of the Missa D'ung aultre amer,
though, tuning considerations come more to the fore, such that sections
of this short mass suggest ambiguities between Pythagorean (as would
have been normal for Ockeghem) & mean-tone (as was becoming more
common in Josquin's lifetime), a "historical" sort of tuning clash
ignored by this rendering.... (Per prior comments around tuning in
recent Ockeghem chanson projects, this mass then presumably gives an
opportunity for a more detailed look at these tuning transitions &
how they're sometimes handled ambivalently in music — not so
unlike Ockeghem's music simultaneously suggesting multiple
modalities....)
So
that's not an investigation for which one would turn to the Tallis
Scholars, who take more of a high level view of "Renaissance music" in
the first place (i.e. downplaying or eliding the medieval transition
from the start...). But the interpretations here, and generally since
this series resumed in 2008 with the Missa Sine nomine,
have been striking & energetic & with a good sense of the
overall characteristics of the masses. It's unfortunate that the first
two programs weren't redone, but the rest make for a solid "backbone"
of major mass interpretations heading into 2021: Maybe several will
still be my favorites in a year, maybe not, but mostly I'm hoping for
more attention to the motets & various other unilluminated corners.
We'll see. It's time to transform the Josquin discography, and I'd be
happy to view the Tallis Scholars series as the last of its
prehistory(!).
[19.11.2020]